Anime Debate

[One Piece] Ace Died in the War Arc — What Would’ve Actually Felt Acceptable to Fans?

Japanese fans revisit Ace’s death in One Piece’s Marineford War. What went wrong, what could’ve worked, and why the debate still hasn’t ended.

2026.01.18

#11 MARINE FORDBig Mom PiratesCharlotte KatakuriEdward Newgate / WhitebeardKobyMarco the PhoenixMarines HeadquartersMonkey D. LuffyPortgas D. AceRed-Haired PiratesRevolutionary ArmySaboSakazuki / AkainuShanksStraw Hat PiratesWhitebeard Pirates

[One Piece] Franky’s Post-Timeskip Design Was a Mistake — And Fans Have Never Really Let It Go

Japanese fans debate whether Franky’s post-timeskip redesign was a bold evolution or a rare One Piece misstep. Full translated comments included.

2026.01.12

BrookCP9FrankyMonkey D. LuffyRob LucciStraw Hat PiratesTony Tony ChopperWorld Government

[One Piece] Is Admiral Ryokugyu’s “Wood” Power the Weakest Among the Admirals? Japanese Fans Debate His Devil Fruit

Japanese fans debate whether Admiral Ryokugyu’s plant-based Devil Fruit is the weakest among the Admirals. Full uncut comments and analysis.

2026.01.11

Aramaki / RyokugyuBeasts PiratesBorsalino / KizaruCharlotte Linlin / Big MomHappo NavyKaidoKuzan / AokijiMarines HeadquartersNico RobinRevolutionary ArmySaboSaiStraw Hat PiratesUncategorized

[One Piece] Is Magellan Actually the Strongest Character in the Series? Japanese Fans Think So

Japanese One Piece fans argue that Magellan may be the strongest character in the series. Full 2018 comment translation and analysis on poison, Admirals, and power scaling.

2026.01.11

#17 LEVELY#18 LAND OF WANOBaroque WorksBeasts PiratesBorsalino / KizaruBuggy’s DeliveryCaesar ClownCharlotte Linlin / Big MomCrocodileGaldino / Mr. 3Impel DownKaidoMagellanMarines HeadquartersMarshall D. Teach / BlackbeardPUNKHAZARD

[One Piece] Did Crocodile Already Awaken His Devil Fruit? Japanese Fans Debate Logia vs “Special Paramecia”

Did Crocodile already show signs of Devil Fruit awakening in early One Piece? Japanese fans debate Logia, special Paramecia, and power scaling retcons.

2026.01.07

#17 LEVELYBaroque WorksBig Mom PiratesCharlotte KatakuriCrocodileDonquixote DoflamingoDonquixote PiratesMonkey D. LuffyStraw Hat Pirates

[One Piece] Luffy vs Goku at the World Martial Arts Tournament — Japanese Fans Seriously Argue Luffy Might Win

Japanese fans seriously debate whether Luffy could defeat Goku under World Martial Arts Tournament rules. Haki, Gear Fourth, Instant Transmission, ring-outs, and anime power logic collide.

2026.01.06

Monkey D. LuffyStraw Hat Pirates

[One Piece] Why Was Luffy Able to Defeat Katakuri? A Full Breakdown

Why was Luffy able to defeat Katakuri despite being overwhelmed for most of the fight? Fans debate durability, future sight, Haki logic, and protagonist privilege in ONE PIECE.

2025.12.30

#16 WHOLE CAKE ISLANDBig Mom PiratesCharlotte KatakuriMonkey D. LuffyStraw Hat Pirates

【ONE PIECE】Was Whitebeard the Weakest Yonko?Kaido > Big Mom >>> Shanks > Whitebeard

Was Whitebeard really the weakest Yonko? Fans compare Whitebeard, Big Mom, Kaido, and Shanks using Marineford battles, crew power, and illness.

2025.12.29

#11 MARINE FORDEdward Newgate / WhitebeardWhitebeard Pirates