Magellan / June 2018 — Could Luffy Ever Win Without Plot Armor?
Magellan is one of those One Piece characters fans still argue about years later.
Was he genuinely unbeatable — or just written that way?
And if Luffy faced him now, would anything actually change?
Is Magellan Fundamentally Unbeatable?
1: Anonymous Pirate
Luffy absolutely can’t win.
2: Anonymous Pirate
He couldn’t beat him back then either.
3: Anonymous Pirate
With his current attack power it’d be a one-punch… but touching him means instant game over, so yeah.
5: Anonymous Pirate
Even with Armament Hardening, is touching him still instant death?
6: Anonymous Pirate
At this point Haki basically makes poison useless anyway.
7: Anonymous Pirate
Aside from his own durability being low enough to almost go down from a gut punch, he’s basically top-tier.
8: Anonymous Pirate
Without protagonist plot armor, he would’ve died.
“Touch = Death” — The Poison Problem
9: Anonymous Pirate
He’s got poison resistance now so it’s easy.
10: Anonymous Pirate
If you throw seastone at him full force, he’d die.
11: Anonymous Pirate
That manga uses insanely strong poison and nobody ever dies.
14: Anonymous Pirate
>>11
For work purposes paralysis poison is enough.
He only used corrosion at the very end, so that’s probably the idea.
12: Anonymous Pirate
He probably won’t show up again since you can’t beat him bare-handed.
15: Anonymous Pirate
Cutting only slices the surface, explosions don’t blow his body apart either.
In that world, punching is still the strongest attack.
Haki, Resistance, and Retcons
17: Anonymous Pirate
Didn’t they say he got wrecked by Blackbeard and retired?
19: Anonymous Pirate
It’s poison that melts concrete, somehow.
28: Anonymous Pirate
Since when did Haki nullify poison?
33: Anonymous Pirate
>>28
At least if you inhale it, it shouldn’t matter.
Maybe it forms a surface barrier or something.
35: Anonymous Pirate
>>33
Haki isn’t Nen, you know.
38: Anonymous Pirate
In that world, damage gets absorbed by Haki first.
Unless you fully drain it, there’s basically no real damage.
Blackbeard, Shiryu, and Power Scaling
21: Anonymous Pirate
He even chased off Blackbeard, one of the Yonko.
22: Anonymous Pirate
It was kind of a surprise attack, but if Shiryu hadn’t betrayed him, he probably would’ve beaten Blackbeard.
23: Anonymous Pirate
If Shiryu is on par with Magellan, that’s insanely dangerous.
25: Anonymous Pirate
Even though Hannyabal is the warden now, Doflamingo still talks like Magellan is there.
Maybe he’s in charge of Level 6?
29: Anonymous Pirate
>>25
He just became the chief warden.
He recovered in two years, so he’s probably guarding lower levels now.
31: Anonymous Pirate
At this point there are poison fish stronger than Magellan anyway.
👉 Why Japanese Fans See Magellan as a “Hard Stop”
Japanese readers consistently frame Magellan as a system breaker, not a normal fighter.
The issue isn’t strength, speed, or technique — it’s that contact itself is forbidden.
In a series where punches ultimately decide everything, Magellan violates the core combat logic.
That’s why fans instinctively conclude:
“Without plot armor, Luffy dies.”
👉 What This Debate Really Says About One Piece Combat
This thread isn’t really about Magellan vs Luffy.
It’s about discomfort with enemies who can’t be overcome through growth, grit, or Haki alone.
When fans argue poison resistance, Haki membranes, or retcons, they’re trying to re-normalize Magellan —
because characters like him expose the limits of One Piece’s battle philosophy.
Magellan isn’t just strong.
He represents a kind of threat the story quietly stopped using.
Comments